Is your legal recruitment process fit for purpose?

· Legal Recruitment Blog

Is your legal recruitment process fit for purpose?

Effective recruitment processes are critical for every organisation.

To identify, attract, and keep the best personnel, you'll need a complete plan that includes everything from crafting an effective job description to conducting a successful interview. After all, successful recruitment is more than just filling a gap in your team; it's about finding the person who will have a long-term impact on the success of your business.

A specialist recruitment firm, such as Legal Recruitment Scotland, can help you identify the right candidate by assessing the available applicants in your industry, particularly those in the legal career field. However, you will still need to consider how you will persuade those candidates to join your team throughout the interview process, especially when recruiting for a vacancy in the legal sector.

Enhancing your Legal Recruitment Process

According to Leadership IQ research, failures among new hires are usually the result of improper interview methods. According to the report, 82% of the 5,000 managers surveyed believed that interviewers lacked the necessary interviewing skills to identify red flags and choose the best candidate, especially in the legal sector.

Interviewing is a challenging procedure that many companies neglect. There's more to it than ensuring that someone has the required technical capabilities for the position.

Interviews also focus on:

  • Cultural compatibility - Determine whether that person will do well in your business environment.
  • Attitude - Determine whether the individual shares your company's ideals and principles.
  • Skills - To succeed in a customer-facing business role, the person must be able to speak well, manage their time effectively, and display proper body language.

It makes sense that the majority of individuals view the interviewing process to be the most challenging aspect of finding talent, given the wide range of factors for the recruiter to take into consideration, including coachability, emotional intelligence, motivation, temperament, and motivation.

Learn What Makes a Successful Hiring Process

The most basic way to ensure that your interviewing and hiring strategy is up to date is to ensure that it includes all of the necessary components. An experienced recruitment company, such as Legal Recruitment Scotland, can assist you with this.

We've detailed some key takeaways for you from this blog.

Provide a Clear Definition of the Position

Before you can start interviewing for a job, you'll need to understand what the position 'looks like'. Creating a clear job description allows applicants to decide if your post is suited for them while also providing your hiring manager with an outline on which to build their opinions about who is "right" for the position.

Explain the following:

  • Responsibilities - Refer to the specific tasks, duties, and functions that a person is expected to carry out as part of their work role.
  • Qualifications - Refers to the abilities, experience, education, and credentials necessary to do a job effectively.
  • Work-Life balance and culture - Refers to the balance between a person's professional and personal life.

Promote the role

With the current job market, promoting your new post is an important aspect of the hiring process. Today's candidates have plenty of options regarding where they can apply their skills. This means that you must go beyond simply posting a job description on your company website.

Connect with a recruitment partner to spread the visibility of the post. We already have ties in the commercial talent market and legal professionals, so we can quickly get your position the attention it deserves.

Plan the interview process

With your job description effectively attracting attention, it's time to move on to the next stage of the talent acquisition process with the help of recruitment agencies. During this stage, you will create a plan for conducting interviews. Remember that many sorts of interviews are accessible based on your objectives.

Screening process - This is the process by which your recruitment firm examines applications for you and removes people who aren't a suitable fit. For example, they can lack the necessary commercial experience or attitude.

Hiring through phone call interview

After your recruiting firm has provided you with a simplified list of prospects, a phone interview will allow your hiring manager to assess each candidate's aptitude to thrive in a role.

In-person Interview

Candidates who performed well in the phone interview will be invited to an in-person interview, where the hiring manager will be able to assess their suitability for the position through competency-based questions and behavioural tests.

Offer the Position

Remember that a successful interview doesn't finish when the last question is answered; it plays a crucial role in securing the right legal career prospect. Employees will also rate the company depending on how you handle the job offer and recruiting process.

To ensure you make the correct impression:

  • Follow up with each candidate promptly, within the time range you established during the interview.
  • Make a plan for onboarding and introducing your new employee to the company on their first day.
  • Help potential employees envision long-term success with your organisation by meeting with them to construct a development plan for future growth.

Prepare Your Hiring Manager for a Successful Interview

As mentioned before, there are many essential elements involved in successful recruiting.

Your hiring manager is an important person in this process. A recruiting manager will conduct your interviews and ensure that your candidates have a positive first impression of your company.

However, recruiting managers do not have many opportunities to practise interviewing. If you aim to impress your candidates, you may need to provide your hiring managers with a little additional assistance.

Inform them about how to score/benchmark candidates.

The job description you create for each position is simply the first step in providing hiring managers with the information they need to make an informed applicant decision. Before you start interviewing, ensure that your hiring manager knows your recruiting plan and what you're looking for in a new employee to fill the vacancy. For example:

  • What level of experience is required? Can you overlook experience if the candidate shows a willingness to learn and engages in regular coaching?
  • Are any certificates required? Is the candidate required to have prior experience with a particular type of software, CRM system, or sales strategy used in a law firm?
  • What kind of mindset will complement your company culture? Do you need someone who can work well in a team or lead others in a law firm environment? Can the candidate effectively express ideas, and do they understand how to manage deadlines?

Assign every characteristic you're looking for a numerical value or a benchmarking type system, similar to the one used in our engage recruitment platform to assist hiring managers in separating the best prospects from the crowd. For example, you may give one point for each year of experience a person has, as well as bonus points for "nice to have" traits such as familiarity with your point of sale system.

Create competency-based questions

The most effective interviewing techniques are structured. When a hiring manager uses the same format for each interview, bias is less likely to interfere with a successful recruiting decision.

Competency-based interviews are an excellent method to learn more about your candidates and what they might bring to the role. List the skills you're looking for, such as:

  • Ability to lead
  • Teamwork
  • Awareness
  • Good communication skills

Create questions that encourage applicants to show their abilities by presenting situational scenarios. For example, typical competency-based questions in the business sector may include:

  • Tell us about a time when you turned an angry customer into a lifelong customer.
  • Can you tell me about a moment when you gave great customer service?
  • Can you tell me about a moment when you were encouraged to improve a product or service?

Efficient competence-based questions can also help your hiring manager develop a scoring approach, as they will be able to give points to each candidate based on their display of a specific competency. You can also use behavioural testing to get a better understanding of your candidate's attitude and ethics.

Ensure a positive candidate experience

Interviews are usually stressful experiences for all parties involved. In today's skills-short market, it's essential to provide prospects with an experience that makes them want to join your team.

Business leaders can assist hiring managers in improving the experience they provide to candidates by setting up "mock" interviews where your "HM's" are advised to:

  • During the interview, take notes and underline each candidate's important competencies and point scores. This improves decision-making and demonstrates that you are attentively listening to their responses while assessing their cultural fit.
  • Develop their body language. The way you present yourself during the interview might make a significant difference. Throughout the interview, hiring managers must have relaxed body language. That includes no crossed arms, slouching, or frequently checking the clock.
  • Respect the candidates. Encourage hiring managers to thank applicants for their time and provide them with information about when they may expect to hear back about their applications. You may also take this chance to remind prospective employees of the benefits they will receive if they accept the position.

Create a Two-Way Conversation

One of the most common mistakes that hiring managers make is to list off questions without really talking with the people on the other side of the desk. A true two-way interaction in an interview demonstrates to the candidate that the company is genuinely interested in them, resulting in a stronger employer brand.

Hiring managers are frequently quite effective at establishing relationships with employees, so encourage them to use such abilities during interviews. This motivates employees to open up and ask questions, giving you a better idea of what they'll be like as an employee.

Enabling candidates to ask a variety of questions allows them to decide whether they think they are a good fit for your company. If they don't think they'll be a good fit, they can inform you right away and prevent you from making a hiring decision that will result in turnover within a few months, particularly in demanding roles within the legal industry.

Pay Attention to Your Reputation

Lastly, make sure you're monitoring how individuals react to your hiring process. Potential candidates in today's recruitment scene frequently seek internal knowledge about the firms they wish to work for. This includes reading reviews on sites like Glassdoor and statements on social media.

To ensure that you are making the right impression on prospects, keep an eye on the recommendations and reviews that surface about your company on the internet. At the same time, consider talking with your candidates at the end of the interview process to solicit feedback on how you might improve.

How can we help you?

At Legal Recruitment Scotland, we recognise the importance of finding the best legal talent for your firm's success. Our specialised recruitment services are intended to ensure that your recruitment procedure is not only efficient but also the perfect fit to your specific needs.

Do not allow a poor recruitment procedure to keep your company back. Partner with Legal Recruitment Scotland to help you establish a successful team.

Contact us today to learn more about how we can help you improve your recruitment procedure!

From the blog

More from the blog

Insight and commentary on legal careers, hiring and employment law in Scotland.

A more thoughtful approach to legal recruitment.

Better for firms. Better for lawyers. Better for the profession.

For firms: start a conversationFor lawyers: speak with us confidentially